LIFESTYLE

Hipsters, Please Don't Culturally Appropriate Holi On Instagram

Learn about this “color festival” you’re celebrating.

25/03/2017 08:46 SAST | Updated 25/03/2017 09:09 SAST

Thousands are expected to crowd outside Utah's Sri Sri Radha Krishna Temple this weekend for what might be the largest celebration of Holi in the United States.

Although Holi is tied to Hinduism, many attendees will likely be young Mormons from nearby schools like Brigham Young University, lured by the promise of big, colorful, messy party.

In recent years, Hindu Americans have found that the Holi celebrations they organize for their own communities are increasingly drawing interest from non-Hindus. The spirit of Holi is one of playfulness and inclusivity, so people of other faiths are often welcomed to join in on the fun.

But there's a fine line between appreciating culture and appropriating culture. The problem happens when people who don't identify as Hindus strip the festival of its spiritual context and history, turning an ancient holiday into a chance for hipsters to throw a raucous party and post the pictures on Instagram.

So before saying "yes" to a friend's invitation to attend a Holi party, it's worthwhile to take a second look at the event itself. The important questions in play seem to be first, whether Hindu Americans are involved in putting on the event, and secondly, whether the organizers acknowledge Holi's origins.

Jim Urquhart / Reuters
Participants crowd surf, dance and throw colored chalk during the Holi Festival of Colors at the Sri Sri Radha Krishna Temple in Spanish Fork, Utah, March 30, 2013.

What You Should Know About The Holiday If You're Going To Participate

Holi is a spring festival that celebrates new life. It's a time when traditional social boundaries are overturned, according to Anantanand Rambachan, a religion professor at St. Olaf College.

"Children can squirt elders, and women can douse the men. Animosities, like the darkness and cold of winter, are forgotten and unity prevails. In the celebration of Holi, we all become one, overlooking differences of age, authority and status," Rambachan told The Huffington Post.

Hindus in the diaspora often organize Holi celebrations for their communities. The festival is popular on college campuses, with South Asian students hosting events open to classmates of all backgrounds.

SAM PANTHAKY via Getty Images
Indian Hindu devotees celebrate the Holi festival at the Swaminarayan Temple in Ahmedabad on March 13, 2017. The Hindu festival of Holi, or the 'Festival of Colours' heralds the arrival of spring and the end of winter.

The History Of What Some Call The Largest Holi Celebration In America

The Festival of Colors USA runs the Spanish Fork event and others in Utah, California, and Nevada. Coordinator Caru Das is a convert who belongs to the International Society for Krishna Consciousness. Popularly known as the Hare Krishna movement, the society has grown from one that primarily drew young, white hippies to one whose ranks are filled with Indian immigrant families. Hare Krishnas put an emphasis on private devotion, but engaging outsiders is also important.

That's what led Das to start hosting Holi at the Spanish Fork temple, over 20 years ago.

"As someone who crossed over from a typical American middle class upbringing to someone who embraced the principles of dharma and reincarnation, I wanted to find a means to make those same treasures available to people from my own background," Das told The Huffington Post.

Das claimed last year's event in Spanish Fork attracted over 37,000 people. He expects a bigger crowd this year.

Despite the festival's growth, Das said it's original intentions are still important. Musicians perform songs filled with mantras. There are yoga demonstrations and performers who explain Holi through dance. Every hour, all attendees are invited to count down from 10 and shout the name of Krishna. For Hare Krishnas, this act of saying Krishna's name is a form of devotion.

Das said that it's not particularly important to him that Holi retains its distinction of being a religious festival.

"As soon as you say Indian or American or Hindu or Christian, you put a barrier between people. You've pulled down a curtain. And I wanted to do not a religious festival, not an ethnic festival, but a spiritual festival that's equally appealing to atheists, Jews, Buddhists, Muslims, Hindus, Christians," he said.

Jim Urquhart / Reuters
Revellers throw coloured powder during Holi at the Sri Sri Radha Krishna Temple in Spanish Fork, Utah, March 26, 2011.

This sense of Holi as a holiday that extends beyond religious and ethnic boundaries seems to be shared by other Hindu Americans.

For Rambachan, Holi is a celebration of life that is "accessible and has universal meaning."

"Many Hindus in the United Sates and elsewhere participate in some aspects of the Christmas season (exchange of gifts, for example) without sharing all its religious meaning," Rambachan said. "In a similar way, I see many who do not identify as Hindus sharing in aspects of Hindu festivals."

For Megha Kalia, a Hindu-Punjabi dance instructor, Holi is a spiritual and cultural event imbued with memories from her childhood in Mumbai. In 2009, she started organizing Holi Hai celebrations in New York City.

Although the festival started primarily for Hindu Americans, over the years it has drawn a following outside of that community. Kalia doesn't mind.

"We are celebrating a festival that celebrates universal brotherhood, love and unity - we couldn't consciously say no to any one community," she told The Huffington Post. "We welcomed everyone with open arms!"

Aminta Kilawan, co-founder of Sadhana: Coalition of Progressive Hindus, said that Holi celebrations in her Indo-Caribbean Hindu community in Queens, New York, are increasingly attended by non-Hindus.

"To some Hinduism is a religion. To some, it is spiritual. To some, it is cultural. The beauty of Hinduism is its malleability and inclusiveness," she said.

Guadalupe Pardo / Reuters
Participants are covered in colored powder as they celebrate in The Color Run in Lima, Peru, August 14, 2016.

Please Stop Diluting Holi As A "Color Run" Or Worse ― "A Feeling Of Woodstock"

But what does trouble Kilawan is when the aesthetics of Holi are used without acknowledging the festival's history.

One series of Holi celebrations, Festival of Colours, was founded by three Germans. Tickets to their 2017 festival in London can cost more than $35. The festival promises to give participants a "feeling of Woodstock."

Another Holi festival, called Festival of Colors: Holi NYC, was reportedly started by a non-Hindu. When asked about whether the festival was a form of cultural appropriation, organizer Jack Langerman was unapologetic.

"I try to be as understanding and respectful of their views as possible," Langerman told Brokelyn in an interview last year. "I understand, given the fact that I'm not Hindu, I'm some white kid who grew up in New York. I understand why that's bothersome. All I can say is, Hindus figured out the best way to celebrate spring."

Requests for comment sent to the European Festival of Colours and Festival of Colors: Holi NYC were not returned.

The Color Run is a running series that holds races in more than 35 countries around the world. During the races, runners are doused with bright powdered colors in a way that is reminiscent of the Holi festival.

Travis Snyder, founder of The Color Run, claims he wanted to add a visual component to the event to serve as an "aesthetic reward" for participants. The Color Run told HuffPost in a statement that Snyder's inspiration came from "day-glow events, Disney's World of Color and color festivals throughout the world."

Kilawan doesn't buy it.

"Let's be honest: if you take a look at photos advertising the event, a logical person could very readily mistake the event for a Holi celebration, and not to any of the other sources," she wrote.

Suhag Shukla, co-founder of the Hindu American Foundation, said that The Color Run is a prime example of cultural appropriation.

"Honestly, there is nothing in the world like the color play that is integral to Holi, so to not acknowledge it comes across as dishonest," she told The Huffington Post.

Rupak De Chowdhuri / Reuters
Students of Rabindra Bharati University blow colour powder during Holi, the Festival of Colours, celebrations inside the university campus in Kolkata, India, March 9, 2017.

When Is A Holi Celebration Cultural Appropriation?

There's a significant difference between events like The Color Run and the Holi festival that attracts tens of thousands of participants in Spanish Fork every year. Even though the Utah event is a wild, big and brimming with college kids, it's a festival run by a Hindu organization that pays homage to Holi's roots as a deeply spiritual holiday. But festivals that ignore the history and philosophy behind Holi risk becoming appropriation.

Shukla said that it all depends on "intent and the respect accorded to the full aspects of the holiday."

"Too often, American pop culture picks and chooses cafeteria-style from Hindu traditions, thereby missing the fundamental spiritual context and purpose, and ending up with what can look and feel like a circus," Shukla told The Huffington Post. "But perhaps rather than making it some hipster or commercial enterprise, people can join local Hindu celebrations to actually enhance their religious and cultural literacy quotient."

Pandit Dasa, a Hindu American and a mindfulness expert based in New Jersey, said that what's happening with Holi now is similar to what happened to yoga.

"Yoga is referenced in the scriptures of Hinduism as a practice that helps you come closer to the divine or God. Obviously [most] yoga studios today have nothing to do with that philosophy," he said.

Dasa said that he's not necessarily against the idea of people practicing yoga for its health benefits or attending Holi festivals just to have a good time, without diving too deeply into their spiritual dimensions. Still, he thinks it would be helpful for attendees to pay attention to Holi's history, and take it upon themselves to do some research before attending festivals.

He also thinks organizers can do their part to educate and explain ― perhaps providing placards and signs explaining why Holi is a spiritual time, and encouraging people to remember their relationship with the divine.

Rambachan believes Holi should be accessible to people of other faiths ― but that it's always good to identify its cultural and religious context.

"This identification is also an act of gratitude for the ways that we are enriched by the traditions of our neighbors and our acknowledgement of indebtedness to these traditions."

Jim Urquhart / Reuters
Participants dance and throw colored chalk during the Holi Festival of Colors at the Sri Sri Radha Krishna Temple in Spanish Fork, Utah, March 30, 2013.