"The buffalo is going down!" was Andile Mngxitama's triumphant comment after Deputy President Cyril Ramaphosa's attempts to prevent the publication of salacious personal details were scuppered by the South Gauteng High Court.
Judge Bashir Vally, during a dramatic night in court 9E in the South Gauteng High Court in central Johannesburg, said Ramaphosa failed to provide the court with enough information to persuade him to grant an interdict. Ramaphosa asked the court to prevent the Sunday Independent from publishing a front-page story on Sunday with details of alleged affairs he had been conducting with a number of women.
Ramaphosa, his wife & supporters will have to be extremely strong especially as they move closer to the conference, dirty tricks on steroids
— Julius Sello Malema (@Julius_S_Malema) September 1, 2017
SUBSCRIBE AND FOLLOW
Get top stories and blog posts emailed to me each day. Newsletters may offer personalized content or advertisements. Learn more
Media has learnt nothing from Polokwane. Journalists and publications chose sides, engaged in factional battles and got played by both sides
— Mbhazima Shilowa (@Enghumbhini) September 2, 2017
Steven Motale, editor of the Sunday Independent, sat next to socialite Kenny Kunene in court. Black First Land First's Mngxitama sat behind them, while Motale was also accompanied by bodyguards. Tyrone Seale, a spokesperson for the deputy president, and Steyn Speed, an adviser to Ramaphosa, were also present.
Advocate Joe Nalane, on behalf of Ramaphosa, argued the deputy president was sent a battery of questions on Thursday night and given until Friday afternoon to respond. Iqbal Survé, owner of Independent News and Media, to whom the Sunday Independent belongs, gave Ramaphosa an undertaking that the story would not be published. However, he was notified on Saturday afternoon that Motale was planning to publish the details of the alleged affairs.
Steve Motale: emails are not only about bursaries but are of a romantic/sexual nature. (Spoke to him not court proceedings) #ramaphosaleaks
— Ferial Haffajee (@ferialhaffajee) September 2, 2017
Iqbal Survé is in China. I just messaged him for court details and he didn't say he had agreed not to publish. #Ramaphosaleaks
— Ferial Haffajee (@ferialhaffajee) September 2, 2017
Advocate David Unterhalter for the Sunday Independent, instructed by well-known media lawyer Dario Milo of Webber Wentzel, told Vally "the horse has bolted" because Motale's detailed questions had been widely circulated on social media since Friday evening. He also revealed that at least one of the women mentioned in Motale's questions to Ramaphosa confirmed the existence of correspondence from the deputy president to her. She also confirmed the content.
Judge Vally asking why does @CR17SIYAVUMA believe he had no time to reply, but could issue a press release Sat? @HuffPostSA #ramaphosaleaks
— Pieter du Toit (@PieterDuToit) September 2, 2017
Nala arguing public interest. Vally: "Public interest not same as interest to the public." @HuffPostSA #RamaphosaLeaks
— Pieter du Toit (@PieterDuToit) September 2, 2017
The Sunday Independent is now expected to publish details of a number of emails purporting to reveal that Ramaphosa has been conducting extra marital affairs with a number of women. Details of these affairs are contained in emails from at least two Gmail accounts that are believed to belong to Ramaphosa. Nalane didn't advance any argument about the validity or otherwise of the emails.
Judge Bashir Vally says #Ramaphosa did not provide sufficient evidence of steps he had taken to engage Sunday Indy. #RamaphosaLeaks
— Ferial Haffajee (@ferialhaffajee) September 2, 2017
In a statement released on Saturday Ramaphosa also did not explicitly deny the allegations contained in Motale's queries to him. He did however explain that some of the women named in Motale's email to him are beneficiaries of study bursaries from him and his wife.
Vally said Ramaphosa's arguments were too slim to force the court's hand. He told Nalane that Ramaphosa does not explain how he might get hurt should the emails be published and that the argument that he did not have enough time to draft a proper reply does not wash: he released two statements on the matter, one on Friday and a comprehensive release on Saturday.
Unterhalter gets up, tells Vally there's no more time. Seems presses are ready to roll. @HuffPostSA #RamaphosaLeaks
— Pieter du Toit (@PieterDuToit) September 2, 2017
Unterhalter gets up, tells Vally there's no more time. Seems presses are ready to roll. @HuffPostSA #RamaphosaLeaks
— Pieter du Toit (@PieterDuToit) September 2, 2017
Nalane did not expand on Ramaphosa's contention in Saturday's press release that state institutions like the intelligence agencies might be involved in fighting factional battles in the run-up to the African National Congress' (ANC) elective conference in December.
The revelations around Ramaphosa's personal life come days after former Minister Trevor Manuel and Deputy Minister Jabu Moleketi were asked to provide the Hawks with statements about activities of a now-disbanded enforcement unit at the South African Revenue Services. This is seen as the pretext to another attempt to prosecute former Minister of Finance Pravin Gordhan, who is regarded as one of the foremost campaigners against state capture. Ramaphosa, a leading candidate to assume the ANC's leadership in December, has built his campaign on efforts against state capture and rent seeking.
Ramaphosa is due to address a campaign event on the West Rand on Sunday. His spokespeople have declined to comment.
