New legislation that makes spanking your child illegal in South Africa caused major controversy this weekend, with many -- including powerful religious groups -- disagreeing with the historic ruling.
The South Gauteng High Court found on Thursday that the common-law defence of "reasonable chastisement" was no longer in line with the Constitution. This judgment closes a loophole that had been used in the past in defence of parents accused of assaulting their children as punishment.
Many celebrated the decision as a win for children's rights in South Africa, where rates of child violence are some of the highest in the world. The Children's Institute Out of Harm's Way issued a report in 2016, which estimates that up to 34% of the country's children are victims of sexual violence and physical abuse before they reach the age of 18.
Wessel van den Berg, child rights and positive parenting portfolio manager for nongovernmental organisation Sonke Gender Justice, told eNCA that the ruling was "crucial".
"Sonke Gender Justice welcomes the ruling as an important step towards children's rights and violence prevention in South Africa," Van den Berg said.
PRESS RELEASE: SA child rights victory as defence of reasonable chastisement ruled out of line with Constitution https://t.co/yW1Ys0fHbE— Sonke (@SonkeTogether) October 20, 2017
"A large body of research shows that there's a strong association between men's use of violence and their exposure to harsh physical punishment as children. This ruling promises to reduce multiple forms of violence. We look forward to working with government and the broader public to roll out education campaigns that ensure parents understand alternatives to corporal punishment and can use nonviolent, positive discipline approaches."
One study conducted over five decades, involving over 160,000 children, found that the more children are spanked, "the more likely they are to defy their parents and to experience increased antisocial behaviour, aggression, mental health problems and cognitive difficulties."
But the court's decision was not welcomed by everyone, with parents and religious groups slamming the judgment. Enraged parents took to social media and expressed defiance of the ruling.
Yeah, I'm just waiting for the brave kids who'll be reporting mom and dad for spanking.— Bridget (@Pickled_Chef) October 23, 2017
Some found the ruling too strict, with many arguing that parents should still be given the right to spank their children, but within the reasonable limits.
Abuse is abuse, but a good parent knows where to draw the line between spanking and abuse. However, the law regards any spanking as assault.— Generall_Vusi (@Vusimah) October 23, 2017
Some also argued that spanking a child was a traditionally "African" method of child-rearing.
@Powerfm987 I'm a product of spanking and I'm proud of my parent it's an African way to discipline a child— Thamie Nyakana🐐♠💣 (@meek_38) October 23, 2017
Religious lobby groups such as the African Christian Democratic Party went one step further and said on Twitter that "criminalising spanking does not achieve [the] desired outcome and diverts resources from where most needed."
#ACDP says criminalising spanking does not achieve desired outcome and diverts resources from where most needed . C Dudley MP@— ACDP South Africa (@A_C_D_P) October 20, 2017
They also said that the decision should not have been the right of a court, but rather of Parliament:
Parliament, the reps of the people, considered this issue thoroughly over many years and concluded that spanking is a family choice— ACDP South Africa (@A_C_D_P) October 20, 2017
The #ACDP regards the judge's conclusion as erroneously equating abuse and violence with reasonable chastisement or a spanking -— ACDP South Africa (@A_C_D_P) October 20, 2017
Tell us what you think in our poll:
Do you agree with the court ruling making it illegal to spank your own child? Tell us why below the poll or DM us. https://t.co/QYid22uoYr— HuffPost SouthAfrica (@HuffPostSA) October 23, 2017