NEWS
21/02/2018 06:47 SAST | Updated 21/02/2018 06:47 SAST

Iceland's Proposed Ban On Male Circumcision Alarms Religious Leaders

Circumcision of male infants is "ethically unacceptable" and violates children's rights, say backers. Religious leaders say it tramples their beliefs.

Anton Podgaiko via Getty Images
A Jewish religious male circumcision ceremony performed by the Stavropol regional Jewish community at the Pyatigorsk synagogue in Russia.

Iceland is considering legislation that would make it the first European country to outlaw male circumcision in children.

The bill proposes up to six years imprisonment for anyone who performs a circumcision on a child that is not for medical reasons, The Guardian reported on Sunday. European religious leaders say the restriction would impinge upon religious freedoms.

Male circumcision is commonly practiced by Jews and Muslims. In countries like the United States, male circumcision is popular across religions and ethnicities. The World Health Organization estimated in 2009 that about one in three men globally is circumcised.

Male circumcision is "a non-negotiable element of Jewish identity," a spokesman for Milah UK, a Jewish campaign group, told The Guardian, adding that Iceland's proposed ban is "extremely concerning."

Cardinal Reinhard Marx, president of the Catholic Church in the European Union, called the proposal a "dangerous attack" on religious freedom.

"Protecting the health of children is a legitimate goal of every society, but in this case this concern is instrumentalized, without any scientific basis, to stigmatize certain religious communities," Marx said last week, according to the Catholic News Agency. "This is extremely worrying."

MANAN VATSYAYANA via Getty Images
A four-year-old Muslim boy is comforted by his father before being circumcised during a ceremony at a mosque in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.

The bill reportedly has strong public support. Advocates say circumcision violates the rights and bodily integrity of children. Silja Dögg Gunnarsdóttir, a member of parliament from the center-right Progressive Party, said she proposed the bill after realizing there were no restrictions on male circumcision in Iceland, even though female circumcision was outlawed in 2005.

"I see it as a child protection matter," Gunnarsdóttir told Euronews. "In Iceland we acknowledge the right to believe but we also acknowledge the right and freedom of everyone to choose and have their opinions."

She added:

I stand by that and I say people should be allowed to have their beliefs for themselves but you have to draw the line when it's about other people.

"Children should also have their own rights for their own beliefs when they are adults."

The bill says people who want to be circumcised for religious or cultural reasons can do so once they are old enough to "understand what is involved in such an action." The age of consent for the procedure isn't explicitly stated.

Male circumcision has long been a controversial issue in Europe. In 2012, Germany ― following months of fierce debate ― ruled that only doctors or trained experts could perform the procedure. In 2016, doctors in Denmark deemed non-medical male circumcisions to be "ethically unacceptable" when performed on children under the age of 18.

The potential health benefits of the practice have also been hotly debated.

Following a comprehensive review of scientific literature, the American Academy of Pediatrics concluded in 2012 that there were "health benefits of newborn male circumcision," such as lower risks of acquiring HIV, genital herpes, and penile cancer, and that these benefits "outweigh the risks," although some experts have disputed the AAP's 'political' findings including saying it "asserts but does not demonstrate" that benefits outweigh risks.

The presumed benefits, nevertheless, were not found to be "great enough to recommend universal newborn circumcision," the group said, adding that the "final decision should still be left to parents to make in the context of their religious, ethical and cultural beliefs."

This article has been altered/enriched by HuffPost SA with Tweets and further points of debate.