The events at Hoërskool Overvaal -- an Afrikaans-medium high school in the ironically named town of Vereeniging (unification) -- brought out the worst in South Africans.
There were anarchic and violent EFF members with posters declaring "war on Afrikaans", an Afrikaans parent with what looked like military regalia (including a Rambo-type knife) standing guard, a charging AfriForum, politically intolerant speeches, police Nyalas trying to calm frayed nerves, and the ANC's biker brigade revving their machines outside the school's gates.
SUBSCRIBE AND FOLLOW
Get top stories and blog posts emailed to me each day. Newsletters may offer personalized content or advertisements. Learn more
On the one side, confused and scared (white) schoolchildren looked on from behind locked gates and fences while, on the other side, excluded and uncertain (black) children stood beside the road with their protesting parents.
It should never, ever have come to this: a school and its children seemingly being used to fight a political and ideological battle by Gauteng MEC for education, Panyaza Lesufi.
Because really, that's the only conclusion one can draw from the judgment by the High Court in Pretoria that set aside the decision by the Gauteng department of education to force Overvaal to enrol 55 English-speaking pupils in the school.
According to the court, Overvaal was full and two English-medium schools in the area had enough capacity to welcome the children. Lesufi and the department, however, tried to bully and intimidate to get their way. For purely political reasons.
No right-thinking South African could ever oppose an underutilised school being filled with children who have no other options, even if that impacts on the language policy of that school. Our history is one of inequality and deprivation, still seen and felt every day. Black children have for centuries been excluded from receiving a high-quality education, and South Africans must insist on their government making it its biggest priority.
By the same token, former Model-C schools must ensure that they reach out to struggling schools, and they need to be accommodating of children from outside their traditional feeder areas. It is the only way we all will survive.
But where is the outrage around Lesufi and his department's gerrymandering of numbers at Overvaal and the two English schools in the vicinity, General Smuts High School and Phoenix High School?
The Constitution guarantees the right to education, and it guarantees the right to mother-tongue education "where that education is reasonably practicable". That is a fine balance to hold, and one which parents and officials, children and interest groups have to navigate every year and with every intake in schools. And it is complicated even more so by our violent and racist history.
But where is the outrage around Lesufi and his department's gerrymandering of numbers at Overvaal and the two English schools in the vicinity, General Smuts High School and Phoenix High School, respectively 9.9km and 7.8km from the Afrikaans school? It is quite extraordinary that Lesufi has been let off the hook -- after the court judgment (which he is appealing) found the department intimidated school principals and manipulated procedure to get its way. It is an appalling abuse of power.
According to EWN's Barry Bateman, Prinsloo found that both General Smuts and Phoenix have capacity to accommodate the 55 English-speaking children, and that Overvaal had reached its capacity.
#HoerskoolOvervaal Prinsloo: there is compelling evidence that neighbouring English school have capacity to accommodate many more than 55 learners. BB— Barry Bateman (@barrybateman) January 15, 2018
#HoerskoolOvervaal Prinsloo: on the weight of the evidence the school has reached its objective entry level learner capacity. The HOD must in any event declare it full. BB— Barry Bateman (@barrybateman) January 15, 2018
But the department never exercised its right to investigate numbers at the school. Instead -- and this is damning, but largely ignored -- it preferred to threaten the other schools' headmasters with dismissal if they didn't amend their affidavits to say that they, too, were full. That after both schools said that they did have capacity.
From Bateman's reporting:
#HoerskoolOvervaal Prinsloo: there is no suggestion that GDE made any effort to verify the capacity at the two schools. BB— Barry Bateman (@barrybateman) January 15, 2018
#HoerskoolOvervaal Prinsloo: refers to the affidavits from a English schools in the area. Phoenix had 125 gr8 on system, but capacity for 240. Gen Smuts also confirmed capacity. BB— Barry Bateman (@barrybateman) January 15, 2018
#HoerskoolOvervaal Prinsloo: had they made any effort they would have discovered the abundance of capacity at two other schools. BB— Barry Bateman (@barrybateman) January 15, 2018
So, if both English schools had capacity and the Afrikaans school is full, what was the problem? All of a sudden General Smuts and Phoenix made an about-turn:
#HoerskoolOvervaal Prinsloo: additional affidavits from the principals were filed to the effect that their first affidavits were incorrect. BB— Barry Bateman (@barrybateman) January 15, 2018
#HoerskoolOvervaal Prinsloo: now dealing with what he calls the "sting in the tail" - the additional affidavits which the principals filed to recant earlier statements that they had capacity at schools. BB— Barry Bateman (@barrybateman) January 15, 2018
But why would the schools' principals suddenly change their tune, saying they were wrong in the first affidavit and that they don't in actual fact have capacity? Did they make a mistake? No, says the judge:
#HoerskoolOvervaal Prinsloo: I find it inherently improbable that these highly-qualified, experienced school principals would make such a vast mistake when making an affidavit. BB— Barry Bateman (@barrybateman) January 15, 2018
When Lesufi and his department saw where it was headed, they intervened because the principals were "helping an Afrikaans school":
#HoerskoolOvervaal Prinsloo: refers to WhatsApp messages which reveal one of the principals was threatened with being fired for supplying affidavit saying he had capacity. BB— Barry Bateman (@barrybateman) January 15, 2018
#HoerskoolOvervaal Prinsloo: another principle summoned to GDE district offices where he was threatened with being fired, accused of being a racist and asked why he was helping an Afrikaans school. BB— Barry Bateman (@barrybateman) January 15, 2018
#HoerskoolOvervaal Prinsloo: the HOD, district director and possibly MEC acted in conflict with the constitutional principle of legality. BB— Barry Bateman (@barrybateman) January 15, 2018
Lesufi gave a fuzzy answer to questions at a press conference on Tuesday on whether he will act against his head of department and district director, who were fingered by the court. "We will deal with it administratively," he said.
That's a fudge and a cop-out.
The MEC is playing fast and loose with the legitimate concerns and fears of many black parents who are struggling to get a quality education for their children. He's also victimising a school and a community whose rights are protected by the Constitution.
That has now led to the horrible events on Wednesday, where parents and children were confronted by the sight of the intolerant and the intolerable turning the first day of school into a traumatic and violent event. It is unacceptable.