The Easter holidays are a time for family and festivities, but they can also be financially challenging. Black tax can put pressure on young professionals to provide, not only for their immediate families, but their extended families as well. While it's a wonderful time of togetherness, this means funds can run dry relatively quickly.
Saying no is often tricky, as black tax is frequently an unspoken pressure – and when money talk is taboo, financial issues are difficult to bring up. I recommend getting a big picture of your finances, knowing what you can afford – and want – to give, and then having the hard conversations with your family.
It's better to be upfront in order to manage expectations and protect your financial wellbeing. Holiday contributions to household essentials can still happen, but this needs to be on your terms, within the constraints of your spending plan.
Can you ask this question ka June 😭😭😭 Easter is here staring us in the eye with its black tax.— Onika 👑 (@nicki_D_) March 28, 2018
Black tax is familiar to many South Africans. In fact, a 2017 survey showed that of the respondents who earned under R6,000 p/m, 26 percent were expected to support their parents and children.
I had a chat with South African actress and model Nomzamo Mbatha about black tax, which has had an impact on her personally. She says she starts prepping for the holidays well in advance.
"In the past, I'd end up buying all kinds of things for my 13 nieces and nephews, along with toys, school uniforms and stationery – at times, to ease the load on my siblings, I'd even pay school fees. But I've learned from experience that if my well runs dry, I can't care for myself, let alone anyone else. So I've cut my spending, and I've started holding my family accountable."
She says she now manages her extended family's expectations by saying no. "Foremost, I think it is such a great privilege to be in a position to be able to help others, especially my family. But I've had to learn that at times its best to say no – which in most black families we're taught not to say.
"There's a difference between needs and wants, and I've learnt to prioritise the things my family really needs. I try and assist in little ways, but I've realised that by not capping the black tax, there's a risk that some of my family may become fully dependent on me. That doesn't empower them; it incapacitates them from ever achieving financial freedom and self-sufficiency. I prefer to empower my family by paying them to do real jobs for me or by sponsoring their educational pursuits."
It's not often spoken about, but often, a relationship can lead to partners inheriting each other's black tax.
For me, learning to say no has also been a journey. I've learnt to approach each vacation with a plan. Here is my advice for managing black tax and saving smartly before holidays hit:
Devise a wise spending plan
Go through your last three bank statements with a fine-tooth comb to understand your spending habits. Get an overview of your debts, overall income and expenditure. Then grab a calendar and diarise your travel dates and any upcoming family events like weddings, etc. Work alongside a financial adviser to set up a budget for the year, taking into account the holidays and celebrations you'll need to save for.
Break the cycle
If you can afford to do so, consider sponsoring a family member's educational or business pursuits, rather than making lifestyle contributions. Think of formalising this by drawing up a contract of sorts, with specific milestones a family member has to meet in order for you to continue sponsoring them – like passing their first year of varsity.
Have a great Easter break Mzansi and I hope black tax doesn't doesn't overwhelm you too much these holidays— Kgothatso Motshele (@Kgothatso_FA) April 13, 2017
Be safe and stay blessed!
Another option is to hire your unemployed family members when you need odd jobs done in order to enable them to learn a skill and earn a small stipend. Black tax is often something that gets passed from generation to generation, so it's important for families to educate young people on how to balance family expectations while setting themselves up for long-term financial independence.
Discuss money matters with your partner
It's not often spoken about, but often, a relationship can lead to partners inheriting each other's black tax. This can exacerbate the expense of the holidays, as both partner's families could have fiscal expectations of a couple. Discuss the holidays and have a spending plan drafted well in advance, so you're on the same page regarding what you're willing to (and more importantly, unwilling to) support for both families.
Leave the bank card behind
Consider withdrawing only the cash you'll need and taking it in an envelope, so you won't be tempted to use your credit card. Alternatively, put the bulk of your salary on your credit card, and take a debit card instead, with limited available funds to curb overspending.
Easter is a special time for families, and many of us see it as a privilege to be able to give to the people we love – but try not to let this be at the expense of your own financial future.
Track using the app
Track your holiday spending using your bank's app or online banking capabilities. This way, you can compare your rate of expenditure with your budget goals.
Pay all your big bills before you go
If possible, make sure you've paid for things like school fees and rent, bond on the first of the month, before you head home.
Open a savings account or sign up for a stokvel
Stokvels can help combat black tax by enabling saving before big events. Their popularity has grown; in fact, 88 percent of black people participate in informal saving schemes like stokvels and burial societies. Some of the more common types of stokvels include:
- Grocery stokvels: These are frequently used to buy groceries in bulk for the family from factory stores that often offer discounts.
- Burial societies: Funeral stokvels and burial societies are used to save for the unexpected. While a funeral policy may help to cover the cost of the actual service, it's unlikely to cover all the travel expenses and other niggling amounts. A stokvel or savings account can, therefore, help supplement the extra and unexpected expenses.
- Education stokvel: Often, people overspend over the holidays, only to find there's no money for school fees come to the new term. Education stokvels and savings accounts help to ensure that important expenses like education are always prioritised.
It's important to adopt a big-picture mindset and think of other things you might need funds for – for example, young men should consider setting up lobola stokvels or savings accounts as soon as they start to earn. Lobola is expensive – which means the tax on a young person's family could be immense if he has insufficient funds to afford the "bride price".
It's important to note that savings accounts can be even more effective than stokvels, often with better interest rates.It's about planning ahead, saving in advance and having the hard conversations to manage your partner's and your family's expectations. Easter is a special time for families, and many of us see it as a privilege to be able to give to the people we love – but try not to let this be at the expense of your own financial future.